When the Veil Grew Thin
c. Edenglow Publishing, LLC ~ October 5, 2026
When the Veil Grew Thin
c. Edenglow Publishing, LLC ~ October 5, 2026
Every family has stories that refuse to die. In mine, there is one about a great-great-aunt, a pair of stockings, and walnuts that appeared where no walnuts had any business being. It sounds wonderfully absurd—until you discover just how deeply nuts, spirits, fortune-telling, and the returning dead were once woven into the traditions of Halloween.
There is a story in my family about a great-great-aunt and a pair of stockings.
I don't know exactly when it happened. As with most stories that survive several generations of retelling, some of the details have probably wandered off on their own. Even the walnuts may not have been walnuts. They may have been some other kind of nut.
But the part the family remembered was this:
Nuts began inexplicably coming out of her stockings.
Not nuts she had hidden there. Not something she was carrying.
They simply appeared.
I grew up with family stories like this. They weren't necessarily presented as grand supernatural revelations requiring investigation. They were simply things that had happened to somebody, somewhere back in the family—strange enough that people continued telling the story long after everyone who witnessed the event was gone.
I have no idea what happened to my great-great-aunt that day.
But I've recently discovered that the walnuts make her story considerably more interesting.
Because once upon a time, nuts belonged to Halloween.
And so did the dead.
Long before plastic pumpkins appeared on porches and miniature candy bars were sold by the hundred, the end of October occupied a peculiar place in the calendar.
In the Gaelic world, Samhain marked the transition from the harvest season into winter. Medieval Irish literature repeatedly places extraordinary events around Samhain: entrances to the Otherworld become accessible, supernatural beings emerge, and ordinary rules seem temporarily less dependable.
Today we often hear this described by saying that "the veil between the worlds was thin."
It is a beautiful phrase.
It is also probably not an ancient one.
The medieval sources don't describe a veil separating the living from the dead that literally became thinner on October 31. That particular language appears to be considerably more modern.
But the idea underneath it has much older bones.
Samhain appears again and again in Irish tradition as a liminal moment—a threshold in the year when encounters with the supernatural were especially possible. The world people knew and the mysterious world beyond it seemed, at least in the stories, unusually close together.
Centuries later, Christian observances surrounding All Saints' and All Souls' Days occupied the same season of the calendar, and customs from different traditions gradually overlapped, traveled and changed.
November 1 became All Saints' Day, or All Hallows, followed by All Souls' Day on November 2. The evening before All Hallows became All Hallows' Eve—and eventually Halloween.
Over centuries, traditions blended, changed, traveled and acquired new meanings. It is nearly impossible to draw a perfectly straight line from one ancient festival to the Halloween we celebrate today.
And perhaps we shouldn't try.
Halloween is less like an heirloom preserved untouched in a glass case and more like an old family recipe.
Everybody added something.
Throughout medieval and later European culture, people prayed for departed souls. In some places, the poor and children went from house to house asking for food in exchange for prayers for the dead—a practice generally known as "souling."
Special soul cakes might be given to the visitors.
Elsewhere came guising: people disguised themselves and traveled from house to house asking for food, fruit, nuts or coins, sometimes offering songs, verses or performances in return.
The resemblance to modern trick-or-treating is impossible to miss, although today's costumed six-year-old demanding a peanut-butter cup is unlikely to offer prayers for Great-Uncle Harold in exchange.
The season was also filled with beliefs about protecting the household.
And the dead were not always imagined as terrifying strangers rattling chains in the darkness.
Sometimes they were your dead.
They were the people who had once sat beside the fire, slept beneath the roof and eaten from the same dishes. Remembering them at the beginning of winter wasn't necessarily frightening.
There is something almost tender about it.
For a little while, perhaps, the distance between the living and those who had gone before did not seem quite so great.
Oddly enough, for all our modern association of Halloween with death, monsters and horror, an enormous amount of traditional Halloween fortune-telling was concerned with one subject:
Marriage.
Who would you marry?
When would you meet?
Would he be rich?
Would she be faithful?
Could you see your future sweetheart's face?
Apparently our ancestors had access to the mysteries of the spirit world for one night a year and immediately asked it about their dating prospects.
They used mirrors, candles, apple peels, cabbage stalks, dreams—and nuts.
Especially nuts.
Historical American newspapers preserve numerous accounts of Halloween fortune-telling inherited from Britain and Ireland. Nuts or chestnuts were thrown into fires and watched carefully. Two nuts might be named for a pair of lovers. If they burned peacefully together, the relationship supposedly had a promising future. If one popped away from the other, things were not looking quite so rosy.
The association became so strong that Halloween was sometimes called Nut-Crack Night.
Apples performed similar duties. A long apple peel tossed over the shoulder might supposedly land in the shape of the first letter of a future spouse's name. Mirrors could reveal faces. Dreams might reveal husbands. Even pulling a cabbage from the ground could become an investigation into one's romantic future.
Nothing in the autumn kitchen was safe from divination.
This is where my great-great-aunt wandered back into the story.
Among the Halloween charms recorded in the early twentieth century is a particularly strange one involving a walnut tree.
At midnight on Halloween, a young man or woman was instructed to walk three times around a walnut tree while asking that his or her true love bring some walnuts.
If the charm worked, the future husband or wife would appear in the tree, gathering walnuts.
There were other walnut charms, too. One recipe intended to provoke prophetic dreams called for a young woman to combine walnut, hazelnut and nutmeg with butter and sugar before going to bed. Her dreams would supposedly reveal something about the man she would eventually marry.
Walnuts, in other words, were not merely autumn food.
They could become instruments for asking questions of the unseen.
Which brings us back to the stockings.
I have found no traditional belief saying that a supernatural manifestation should cause walnuts to come tumbling mysteriously from a woman's stockings. As far as I can determine, that particular contribution to folklore belongs to my family.
But I find the coincidence delightful.
Somewhere along the way, my family preserved a story about a woman experiencing an unexplained event involving nuts. Generations later, I discovered that nuts—and walnuts specifically—had once been intimately connected with Halloween divination, fortune-telling and attempts to glimpse what ordinary eyes were not supposed to see.
Does that explain what happened?
Of course not.
But it makes me wish someone had asked my great-great-aunt a few more questions.
When immigrants from Ireland, Scotland, England and elsewhere crossed the Atlantic, their traditions crossed with them.
In America, old customs mingled with new ones.
Turnips eventually gave way to pumpkins, which were considerably more cooperative when somebody decided to hollow one out and carve a face into it. Old-world guising and door-to-door customs became part of the complicated ancestry of trick-or-treating. Fortune-telling games appeared at Halloween parties. Newspapers in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries cheerfully published instructions for discovering future husbands with mirrors, nuts, apples and candles.
Halloween gradually became less solemn and increasingly social.
There were parties.
There were pranks.
There were costumes.
There were games designed to frighten young women into screaming and games designed to tell those same young women whom they were going to marry.
Ghosts remained, but increasingly they were decorations.
The mysterious visitor at the door became the neighbor's child wearing a sheet.
The food left out became candy handed directly into a plastic bucket.
The carved vegetable became a glowing pumpkin on the porch.
The old traditions did not exactly disappear.
They changed clothes.
We can explain much of October's atmosphere without invoking a single ghost.
The days shorten dramatically. Plants die back. Leaves fall from trees that only weeks earlier were green. Migrating birds disappear. Fields are harvested and left bare. Cold arrives after dark. Fog hangs over roads and fields. Houses that seemed ordinary in July look entirely different beneath naked branches and an October moon.
For agricultural people, this transformation was far more consequential than it is for most of us today.
Winter was coming.
The harvest was finished or nearly finished. Food had to last. Animals had to survive. Darkness occupied more and more of every twenty-four hours.
The natural world itself seemed to be withdrawing.
It isn't difficult to understand why people standing at that particular threshold of the year might also think about death.
Nor is it difficult to understand why they might think about the dead.
Autumn demonstrates, rather dramatically, that disappearance is part of the natural order.
And yet spring will come again.
Perhaps that contradiction—death surrounding us while we know life is merely waiting—is part of what has always made this season feel different.
I don't know whether there is a veil between worlds.
I certainly don't know whether it gets thinner in October.
History can't answer that question.
What history can tell us is that human beings have spent a very long time standing in autumn darkness and wondering whether somebody might be standing just beyond the firelight.
We disguised ourselves.
We lit fires.
We carved frightening faces.
We prayed for the dead.
We left food.
We told stories.
We asked apples whom we would marry and threw nuts into flames to see whether love would last.
And when something happened that we couldn't explain, we told somebody else.
That person told another.
And another.
Until eventually, perhaps a century later, a woman sits at her computer in October writing about a great-great-aunt she never knew and the walnuts that supposedly came out of her stockings. (An unexplainable pinwheel incident occurred at the grave of this same great-great aunt, but that's a story for another day.)
Maybe that is another kind of thinning veil.
Not one between this world and some supernatural realm, but between the present and the past.
Every family story we remember makes that boundary a little more transparent.
For a moment, people whose lives ended long before ours began step forward again. We know what frightened them. What amused them. What embarrassed them. What they believed. What strange thing happened one afternoon that nobody could explain.
We say their names.
We tell their stories.
And just like that, the dead aren't quite so far away.